Sunday, September 23, 2007

Blog 11: The Fog of War

Robert McNamara presents 11 lessons for us to consider over the course of the documentaty, The Fog of War. One that sticks out to me is Lesson #9: In order to do good, you may have to engage in evil.

McNamara starts out his argument for this lesson by talking about the morals that go into war. What makes one thing right and what makes something else wrong? He talks about America's use of Agent Orange in Vietnam as his prime example. Agent Orange was used to strip the leaves off trees in order to cut back on the guerilla warfare. What was not known at the time was that Agent Orange also was a toxin that caused cancer as well genetic defects in those exposed to it. This primarily affected American soldiers and more than anything else the innocent citizens in Vietnam.

In total, millions of Vietnamese civilians were killed in the conflict of the Vietnam War. McNamara says this is ok for the simple reason that the bombing and attacking of Vietnamese villages meant that less troops had to see actual combat. As an American I see the benefit of this but at the same time it does not seem "fair" that all of this would happen to innocent civilians.

In the context of war, this lesson is very prevalent. I mean war is at its root, evil. More than anything else war is an evil thing that results in countless murders and deaths. At the same time war can be fought for the greater good, unfortunately most of the time it is not though and it is fought for personal gains and aspirations for power.

Overall, the main counter-argument is that the majority of good is indeed done with no evil having been done. Two of the most poignant examples of this peaceful protest is the work of Gandhi in India and Martin Luther King Jr. during the civil rights movement. Gandhi is famous for peaceful protest and without him India might have had to take place in a brutal civil war to gain independence. Instead they had a leader who believed in peaceful protest and in the end they won their independence without the bloodshed typical of a country in their situation. Martin Luther King Jr. also prescribed to a system of peaceful protest and used this to help minorities gain their civil rights in the turmoil of the 1950's and 1960's.

These two men are prime examples that a lot of good can be done by engaging in no evil and having a steadfast commitment to their dreams. That is the main issue that I have with the 9th lesson that McNamara presented. I really feel like evil is almost never necessary to promote the greater good. Goodness in itself will typically just lead to more goodness.

1 comment:

Rajat Jain said...

I would like to inform you a little about India's independence movement. While Gandhi wanted India's independence movement to be peaceful, it is recorded as one of the most violent and bloody events in India's history. During the time of partition alone 'at the lowest estimate, half a million people perished and twelve million became homeless' [Source: Wikipedia]. The majority of the people dead died in Hindu-Muslim riots. Through-out India's enslavement, thousands died each day due to poverty, overwork, disease or British brutalities. Some people felt that there was a need for a radical movement to oust the British and we did have revolutionaries and organized movements but it was Gandhi who was respected by both the Hindus and Muslims and who in essence unified the country. Many people believe that had he adopted an aggressive policy, India would have not only achieved freedom earlier but also paid a lesser price in terms of the number of lives lost. I personally support that notion too. Passive resistance to the British was our mistake. People believe that we won our freedom due to Gandhi's non-violence movement which is far from truth. We gained freedom due to the destabilization of the pillar of British power in India —- the British Indian Armed forces. In addition, the British people and the British Army seemed unwilling to back a policy of repression in India and other parts of the Empire even as their own country lay shattered by the war's ravages.