Thursday, November 22, 2007

Blog 36: Born into Brothels

Personally, I am not entirely sure if it is ok that these children's lives are on display. I doubt that they had any say in whether or not they were in the film. At the same time, I am sure that when they agreed to take the class with Briski and receive the free cameras that there was an arrangement that they would be in the film. She obviously went and started this class with the intention of making a difference and if that is the means to this end then it is necessary.

Also, it is not as if we are seeing every moment of these children's lives. She did not follow every children around 24/7, she just followed them for certain portions of the day and probably alternated between the different children and the brothel that they resided in.

I choose to believe that in the end, the "ends" do justify the "means." I think that overall, America focuses too much on big statistics and making a change upon the entire situation. We often forget to realize that a difference can be made on a smaller level too. That one person is possible of making a difference. Yes, obviously it won't be as lasting and as big an area will not be change. But the fact that one person is willing to go into a troubled area and give time and energy to try and make a difference should be commended.

I think overall that this movie was a success. These children who previously had almost no hope of living a good life, are now all in high school with the possibility of going to college. Briski has motivated them to stay in school and make a difference through education. And through funding provided by her movie and her organization all of the kids have the money to go to college. Without the movie, none of them would be able to afford college.

The greatest good that can come out of the movie now, are two things. One, that the funding provided by donations and sold copies of this movie will help Kids with Cameras to grow in other areas. Two, that the children who were in the movie can make more of themselves and then return to their home and make more of a difference.

No comments: